Fiber reactive dye vs pigment: the radish and the beet
By Mike Fowler · September 21, 2026
Think of a radish and a beet. Cut a radish and it is white inside: the red lives only on the skin. That is pigment. Cut a beet and it is red all the way through. That is dye. Pigment sits on top of the fiber; dye impregnates it.
Fiber reactive dye
The professional choice, and what most of the book assumes. Procion MX bonds chemically to cellulose, becoming part of the fabric. Colors are vivid and last for years. It needs soda ash, chemical water and a long cure, and it works at room temperature.
A little history: in 1956, chemists in Britain developed a reactive dye for cotton and linen, sold as Procion MX. It was fast, worked at low temperature and was cheap. The patent has expired, so you will see many MX colors under other names, but it remains the most colorfast and lightfast dye readily available.
Pigment
Color fixed to the surface with a binder. It is non-toxic and largely chemical free, needs no powder dyes and no soda ash, works on synthetics, blends and cotton alike, and is set once it is dry. The tradeoffs: a slightly stiffer hand, less brilliant color, and it can fade with heavy washing.
Which to choose
Fiber reactive dye on cotton for the results you are picturing. Pigment when the fabric is not cotton, when you cannot use powder dyes or chemicals, or when you need color set the moment it dries, such as a party or classroom. The folds are identical either way.
Every fold, recipe and fix in this article comes from Art of Tie-Dye, Mike Fowler's complete guide to folding, tying and dyeing.